Behavioral Interview Questions for Employers: 40 Examples by Competency

Ask two candidates for a team-lead role how they handle a teammate’s missed deadline, and you may hear two kinds of answer. One is a principle: “I always raise problems early.” The other is an episode: a handover that slipped one Friday, a conversation on Monday and a checklist the team still uses. Only the episode gives an interviewer something to score.

Behavioral interview questions ask candidates what they did in specific past situations, and they work best inside a structured interviewstructured interview: A job interview in which every candidate is asked the same questions, drawn from an analysis of the job, and each answer is rated against a scale written in advance. It predicts job performance better than an unstructured conversation.Full entry in the glossary, where every candidate gets the same questions, the same follow-ups and the same written scoring scale. To use them well:

1. Pick four to six competencies the job needs
2. Choose one or two past-behavior questions for each
3. Plan the follow-up probes in advance
4. Score every answer on a STAR-shaped rubric
5. Leave out anything that touches a protected characteristic

The interview is one stage of a complete hiring process, and the case for structure itself is in how structured interviews outperform free-form ones.

Prefer to watch? The video covers the same ground as this article.

VideoBehavioral Interview Questions: How Employers Ask and Score ThemWiserHours

Past behavior tells you more than a hypothetical

Behavioral questions rest on a premise set out in the US Office of Personnel Management’s (OPM) 2008 structured interview guide: how someone behaved in similar circumstances before is the best guide to how they will behave on the job. Situational questions, by contrast, describe a realistic job dilemma and ask what the candidate would do.¹

In a 2002 meta-analysis, Paul Taylor and Bruce Small found that past-behavior questions scored on descriptively anchored rating scales predicted job performance substantially better than situational questions rated on anchored scales too.²

The study

Moderate evidence

Did-do versus would-do questions across pooled interview studies

The authors pooled structured interview studies using either question type. With descriptively anchored rating scales, the mean estimated validity (the correlation between interview scores and job performance, where 0 means no link and 1 perfect prediction) was .63 for past-behavior questions against .47 for situational ones. Interviewers agreed with each other about equally well with either format, provided both used anchored scales.²

A 2014 review by Julia Levashina and colleagues put past-behavior questions only slightly ahead overall, so trust the direction more than the size.³ Paul Sackett’s team argued in 2022 that range-restriction corrections common in older meta-analyses overstate validity; their re-analysis of the much-cited 1998 summary by Frank Schmidt and John Hunter put structured interviews first.⁴

Where the advantage is largest is disputed. Allen Huffcutt and colleagues’ 2004 meta-analysis found situational questions less valid for high-complexity jobs, but not past-behavior questions.⁵ Taylor and Small found no support for that pattern.²

The reason is easy to picture, though the studies did not test it directly. Asked what they would do about a teammate’s missed deadline, most people can recite the textbook response: speak privately, early and calmly. Asked what they did last time, they show whether they did it, with details you can probe.

40 behavioral interview questions by competency

Each question below asks for one real episode, and many pin it down with a word such as “last” or “hardest”, as OPM’s guide recommends, to help candidates focus on specific incidents.¹ “How do you usually handle conflict?” invites a summary of good intentions; “the last time” makes the candidate pick one day, which the probe can test.

A support-team lead role might use questions 31, 12, 8 and 28: customer focus, communication, problem solving and integrity. The questions are our own examples; adapt them to the role.

Teamwork

Problem solving

Communication

Leadership

Adaptability

Integrity

Customer focus

Planning and organizing

Read the two right-hand columns beforehand: the strong-answer column describes a 3 or more on the rubric, and the probe gives every candidate the same nudge toward specifics.

A five-level STAR rubric for scoring answers

A STAR-shaped rubric scores each answer by its evidence: a real situation, the candidate’s own actions and a result, following the STAR outline (situation, task, action, result). OPM’s guide calls for one rating scale across all competencies, with at least three levels and ideally five to seven, and example behaviors written for each level.¹

The rubric below is our own. It borrows one idea from OPM’s sample scale: higher levels mean the competency was applied in harder situations.¹ A polished account of a simple problem therefore stops at 3.

• Score 5: everything in 4, plus a lasting fix the person put in place afterwards
• Score 4: everything in 3, in a harder situation, with the reasons for each choice
• Score 3: one specific situation, the person’s own actions in order, and a stated result
• Score 2: a real episode, but vague about the person’s own actions, or with no result
• Score 1: no episode: a general claim (“I always…”) or what they would do

Bar parts: situation (pale, or purple when harder), action (light teal), result (teal), lasting fix afterwards (amber).

Probes give a thin answer a fair chance to climb. OPM’s guide groups them by situation, action and outcome, with examples such as “What is the first thing you did?”, and says their meaning should not change from one candidate to the next.¹ Scored this way, the principle answer from the opening gets a 1; the episode gets at least a 3, and the checklist still in use could lift it to a 5.

Myth

A confident, fluent answer is a strong answer.

Fact

Fluency is not evidence. Score the situation, the candidate's own actions and the result, whatever the delivery.

Candidates practice how to structure a STAR answer too; a rubric asking for specific actions and results still exposes rehearsed generalities.

Before the first interview

• Choose four to six competencies from the job
• Pick one or two questions for each and write one probe per question
• Write example answers for scores 1, 3 and 5
• Check every question against the protected characteristics where you hire
• Agree that each interviewer scores alone before any discussion

Download PDF ↓

Get this checklist as a one-page PDF. We'll email you the download link.

Your emailAlso send me the weekly newsletter (launching soon)Email me the PDF

We use your address to send this link and, only if you tick the box, the newsletter. Privacy policy.

Questions to avoid because they touch protected characteristics

Cut any question whose answer would reveal a characteristic that discrimination law protects where you hire, such as family plans, religion, age, health or national origin. Protected grounds and exceptions vary by country, so treat these examples as a starting point, not a legal checklist.

The international baseline is the International Labour Organization’s 1958 Discrimination (Employment and Occupation) Convention. It treats as discrimination any distinction based on race, colour, sex, religion, political opinion, national extraction or social origin that impairs equal opportunity in employment, but not one based on a job’s inherent requirements.⁶

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) guidance for US employers, checked in September 2026, confines pre-hire questions to what an employer needs to judge whether someone is qualified, and advises against questions likely to reveal an applicant’s religion, age, race, sex or national origin.⁷ Its list of inquiries that may be taken as evidence of discriminatory intent includes pregnancy, plans to marry, the number and ages of children, and child care arrangements.⁸ Under US law, employers generally may not put disability-related questions to applicants until a conditional offer, though they can ask whether an applicant would need an accommodation to do a specific job duty.⁹

In Great Britain, Acas guidance last updated in June 2026 names nine protected characteristics, including sexual orientation, gender reassignment, and pregnancy and maternity. It also says employers must not ask applicants about health or disability at any stage unless an exception applies, for example to find out whether the assessment itself needs adjustments.¹⁰ Elsewhere, check the national equality law, the labour ministry or equality body, or an HR professional.

Behavioral questions carry a trap of their own. Ask for “a time you handled a personal setback” and a candidate may describe an illness or a divorce. Anchor every question to work (“a setback on a project”), and if a candidate volunteers something personal, steer back to work and keep it out of the notes and the score.

The right-hand examples are illustrations: whether a job-related question is lawful still depends on local law and on putting it to every candidate.

If no possible answer could change a candidate’s score on a job competency, drop the question.

The bottom line

Build the interview on what candidates did and rate every answer against anchors agreed in advance. Give everyone the same questions and probes, and reward the situation, actions and result. Test every question against the job and local discrimination law before it goes on the list.